Desperately Seeking Pure Style Indexes

Noël Amenc, Robert Faff, Lionel Martellini: There is an urgent need for improved measurement and benchmarking of size and booktomarket (style) performance.

Author(s):

Noel Amenc

EDHEC Graduate School of Business and Misys Asset Management Systems

Robert Faff

Department of Accounting and Finance, Monash University

Lionel Martellini

EDHEC Graduate School of Business

Given the proliferation of choice, a potentially serious problem is that existing style indexes can provide a somewhat confusing picture of the return on these factors. In this paper, we present detailed evidence of strong heterogeneity in the information conveyed by competing indexes. We also report disturbing evidence that this heterogeneity poses serious problems, not only for modern portfolio analysis, but also for empirical tests of asset pricing theory. This is somewhat reminiscent of Roll’s (1977) critique of CAPM: if the “true” book-to- market and size factors are not observable, and if there is very little robustness with respect to the choice of the proxy used in empirical tests, then the relevance of these factors in asset pricing theory may never be empirically testable. As an attempt to address some of these problems, in exploratory analysis we suggest various methodologies designed to help extract a “pure style index” from competing index returns.

Type: Working paper
Date: le 01/01/2003
Research Cluster : Finance

See Also

EDHEC partners KPMG on a new training programme for family businesses, Family Shift
News
- 25-10-2021
On 14 October, Benoît Arnaud, Director of Programmes at EDHEC Business School and Axel...
AGORA MEETS BERTRAND BADIE, POLITICAL SCIENTIST AND INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS SPECIALIST
News
- 21-10-2021
Agora students held another 'Rencontre de l'Agora' event on Wednesday 19 October, this...
Eiffel Excellence Scholarship: the most prestigious French scholarship you can get
News
- 21-10-2021
Mikhail Miroshnichenko joined EDHEC MiM Finance after his Bachelor’s degree in...
EDHEC-Auchan Learning Partnership: Retail industry transformations at the heart of EDHEC International BBA learning
News
- 20-10-2021
Auchan is joining forces with EDHEC to share its retail industry expertise with EDHEC...