Fundamental Differences? Comparing Alternative Index Weighting Mechanisms

While an ever increasing share of equity assets is invested in indexing strategies, the standard practice of using capitalisation weighting to construct stock market indices has been the object of much criticism.

Author(s):

Noel Amenc

Professor of Finance and Director of Research and Development at EDHEC Business School.

Felix Goltz

Senior Research Engineer and co-head of the Indices and Benchmark Research Programme with the EDHEC Risk and Asset Management Research Centre.

Veronique Le Sourd

Eenior research engineer at the EDHEC Risk and Asset Management Research Centre.

In response to this criticism, equity indices with different weighting schemes have emerged. Some indices use fundamental metrics (Arnott, Hsu, and Moore 2005) to weight the component stocks. In recent years, the market for such characteristics-based indices has grown tremendously, with more and more providers launching offering them. Institutional investors have allocated significant amounts to these alternatives to value-weighted indices. Likewise, a wide range of exchange-traded funds on these new indices is now available. The commercial success of characteristics-based indices has been accompanied by lively debate in the industry and among researchers. Proponents of characteristics-based indices put forward a theory that attempts to show that capitalisation weighting leads to a performance drag in the presence of mispricing in the stock market (see Treynor 2005, Hsu 2006, Arnott and Hsu 2007, and Chen, Chen, and Bassett 2007). However, it has been argued these papers are based on inconsistent assumptions (Perold 2007 and Kaplan 2008).

Type: EDHEC Publication
Date: le 21/04/2008
Research Cluster : Finance

See Also

EDHEC Faculty welcomes Oxford professor Renée B. Adams for a reseach seminar
News
- 11-09-2019
On September 12, 2019, EDHEC faculty will be delighted to welcome Oxford professor...
Riccardo Rebonato will unveil the results of the 12th EDHEC-Risk European ETF & Smart Beta Survey on Sept 23 in London
News
- 03-09-2019
Riccardo Rebonato, Professor of Finance, EDHEC Business School, EDHEC-Risk Institute,...
Launch of the
News
- 03-09-2019
EDHEC Business School and Scientific Beta have announced the launch of the “Advanced...
8 professors appointed in 2019-2020
News
- 27-08-2019
EDHEC Business School appointed 8 new professors for the 2019-2020 academic year. Six...