Hedge Fund Indices from an Academic Perspective: Reconciling Investability and Representativity

Following a growing concern among investors about the quality of hedge fund index return data, and given the lack of capacity and transparency specific to that industry, this paper questions from an academic perspective whether it is feasible or not to design hedge fund benchmarks satisfying all defining properties for a good index.

Author(s):

Lionel Martellini

Professor of Finance, Edhec Graduate School of Business,Scientific Director, Edhec Risk and Asset Management Research Centre

Mathieu Vaissie

Research Engineer, Edhec Risk and Asset Management Research Centre

Felix Goltz

Research Engineer, Edhec Risk and Asset Management Research Centre

In particular, in an attempt to test whether achieving investability necessarily comes at the cost of representativity, as sometimes claimed by hedge fund index providers, we borrow from the asset pricing literature the concept of factor replicating portfolios and apply it to the benchmarking of hedge fund style returns. Our results suggest that it is actually possible to construct representative indices based on a limited number of funds, except perhaps in the case of Equity Market Neutral strategies, provided that i) these funds are suitably selected and ii) an optimal portfolio is designed with the objective of replicating the common trend in hedge fund returns for a given strategy. A wide range of tests are performed that show that high correlation of the factor replicating portfolios with the common factor of returns for each strategy is remarkably robustness with respect to modifying the number of funds in the replicating portfolio, choosing less correlated funds, changing the frequency of rebalancing, using a static selection of funds or imposing constraints on weights.

Type: Working paper
Date: le 14/09/2004
Research Cluster : Finance

See Also

EDHEC career support at distance: continuous follow-up and a highly active network
News
- 05-06-2020
After fully digitalising its services, the EDHEC Student Career Centre has been...
How I got my dream internships
News
- 02-06-2020
I originally wanted to be a footballer. I daydreamed about training with the top...
« EDHEC, the best experience of my life so far »
News
- 29-05-2020
WHAT IS YOUR EDUCATIONAL BACKGROUND PRIOR TO EDHEC? Prior to EDHEC, I pursued a...
Meet Valentin Grinner, Pre-Master student
News
- 28-05-2020
Valentin Grinner “I’ve started a MOOC to learn web development” Valentin, 20, is...