Improved Beta? A Comparison of Index-Weighting Schemes

This paper analyses a set of equity indices whose aim is to improve on capitalisation weighting and thus to provide “improved beta”.

Author(s):

Noel Amenc

Professor of finance and director of EDHEC-Risk Institute.

Lionel Martellini

Professor of finance at EDHEC Business School and scientific director of EDHEC-Risk Institute.

Felix Goltz

Head of Applied Research at EDHEC-Risk Institute.

Lin Tang

Research Analyst at EDHEC-Risk Institute.

Four main weighting schemes are analysed: efficient indices, fundamental indices, minimum-volatility indices, and equal-weighted indices. Empirical results for US data on these indices show that the average returns of all four alternative index construction methods are superior to those of cap-weighted equity indices and that, by several measures of risk-adjusted performance, they are likewise superior. With the notable exception of fundamental indices, which have substantial exposure to the value factor, none of the aforementioned weighting schemes has a significant style bias. Our analysis suggests that their superiority to capitalisation weighting can be explained by better diversification rather than by greater exposure to rewarded risk factors.

Type: EDHEC Publication
Date: le 18/04/2011
Research Cluster : Finance

See Also

17 NEW STARTUPS JOIN THE EDHEC ENTREPRENEURS ADVENTURE
News
- 25-01-2022
2022 looks promising! EDHEC Entrepreneurs and its team are very pleased to welcome 17...
Climate change: a new type of risk for the financial industry?
News
- 25-01-2022
Climate change has been recognized as a new type of risk for finance by academics and...
Meet a student: the power of EDHEC’s Alumni network
News
- 25-01-2022
Junjie Feng joined EDHEC’s Master in Management-Business Management in 2019. He will...
The fight against climate change central to the EDHEC-Coursera specialisation
News
- 21-01-2022
EDHEC Business School launched the “Climate Change and Sustainable Investing”...