The Myths and Limits of Passive Hedge Replication

In this paper we provide a detailed critical analysis of various methodologies involved in the so-called passive replication of hedge fund returns, a subject that has sparked renewed interest following recent initiatives by major investment banks such as Merrill Lynch and Goldman Sachs.

Author(s) :

Noel Amenc

Professor of Finance and Director of the EDHEC Risk and Asset Management Research Centre

Walter Gehin

Research Associate, EDHEC Risk and Asset Management Research Centre and Business Analyst, Atos Euronext Market Solutions

Lionel Martellini

PhD, Professor of Finance and Scientific Director of the EDHEC Risk and Asset Management Research Centre

Jean-Christophe Meyfredi

PhD, Professor of Finance and Research Associate with the EDHEC Risk and Asset Management Research Centr

In particular, we examine from both a theoretical and an empirical standpoint the respective benefits and limits of the two different and somewhat competing approaches to hedge fund replication, which are respectively known as "factor-based replication," and "payoff distribution replication." On the one hand, we argue that standard implementation efforts of the factor-based approach, arguably the most natural and straightforward way to tackle the hedge fund replication problem, have mostly failed in thorough empirical tests to produce satisfactory results on an out-of-sample basis. We also argue that the payoff distribution approach, on the other hand, while insightful and found to generate (relatively) satisfying results on an out-of-sample basis, unfortunately cannot be regarded as a method suitable for performing hedge fund replication, at least not in a sense likely to meet investors' expectations, due to its documented failure to match a number of relevant time-series properties of hedge fund returns. In conclusion, hedge fund replication, while obviously a powerful and attractive concept, is still, at least in terms of successful implementation, very much a work-in-progress. Our analysis suggests that it is only through the introduction of novel adapted econometric techniques allowing for a parsimonious statistical estimation of the dynamic and/or non-linear functions relating underlying factors to hedge fund returns that hedge fund replication could be turned from an attractive concept into a workable investment solution, and we discuss several possible directions for future research.
Pdf
The Myths and Limits of Passive Hedge Replication...
(-1.00 B)
Type : EDHEC Publication
Date : le 04/06/2007
Extra information : Pour plus d'informations, nous vous prions de vous adresser à Joanne Finlay, Direction de la recherche de l'EDHEC [ joanne.finlay@edhec.edu] Les opinions exprimées sont celles de l'auteur et n'engagent pas la responsabilité de l'EDHEC.
Research Cluster : Finance

See Also

Assets replicating Scientific Beta’s multi-factor indices reach USD 25bn
News
- 22-02-2018
Scientific Beta, the smart beta index provider offshoot of EDHEC-Risk Institute, has...
EDHEC Named France National Champions of the KPMG International Case Competition
News
- 20-02-2018
Impact Consulting, a team of four, EDHEC M1 Business Management students, are national...
Investing in Relationships: Why trust matters in private banking
News
- 19-02-2018
  The presentation, The Private Banking Industry – Current Mapping and Future...
EDHEC Global MBA OPEN DAY
News
- 16-02-2018
Looking to advance your career ?  Join the Global MBA team for an exclusive OPEN...