Never the Twain Shall Meet?

This paper reviews the arguments for and against the decoupling of capital ratio calculations based on IFRS from those based on Basel II.

Auteur(s) :

Paul Klumpes

Professor of Accounting, EDHEC Business School

Peter Welch

Independent Banking Consultant

Présentation :

We analyse recent trends in both accounting and regulatory supervision after the financial crisis and identify areas where there are still deficiencies in the transparency of IFRS-based financial reports and regulatory-based capital disclosures and calculations. We find that the variation in disclosure practices across IFRS and BIS-based capital estimations is significant for a sample of major European banks. We also identify how, for a large Swiss bank, variations in IFRS asset and capital bases for capital ratio calculations can make disclosures more transparent. We find evidence that the extent of variation between regulatory-based capital and IFRS-based capital is related to the size of the bank, the extent of off-balance-sheet activities and subordinated debt, the net interest margin, return on assets, value added, and productivity per employee. Variation in disclosure of the leverage ratio is related to bank size, subordinated debt exposure, return on assets, and cost efficiency. We recommend that banks enhance the scope and nature of the reconciliation of IFRS to BIS-based capital ratios to improve the efficiency of markets in reducing information asymmetry about these variations.

Pdf
Never the Twain Shall Meet?...
(2.54 MB)
Type : Position paper
Date : le 22/02/2011
Complément d'informations

For more information, please contact Joanne Finlay, EDHEC Research and Development Department [ joanne.finlay@edhec.edu ] The contents of this paper do not necessarily reflect the opinions of EDHEC Business School.

Pôle de recherche Analyse Financière et Comptabilité

A voir également

- 22-04-2017
Nicolas Hulot, portant la double casquette de reporter-journaliste et d’homme politique, est pleinement engagé dans ses actions en faveur d’une prise de conscience du risque écologique....
Les Entretiens de Nice : Questions d'Education
- 12-04-2017
Le Pôle de recherche en économie poursuit ses conférences dans la cadre du second cycle...
- 04-04-2017
En 2017, l’EDHEC se distingue de nouveau comme l’école de commerce française ayant obtenu le plus de « A », avec une mention spéciale pour son excellence de l’enseignement (quatre...
Frédéric Oudéa, Directeur général de la Société Générale à la rencontre des étudiants de l’EDHEC
- 31-03-2017
La Société Générale est l'une des 3 banques du CAC 40. Son Directeur général a choisi,...