EDHEC-Risk’s annual European ETF Survey confirms satisfaction levels and investor approval of ESMA guidelines

Written on 28 March 2013.


Among the key findings of the 2012 survey:

• ETFs remain the favourite choice of investors for passive investment, in spite of the controversies surrounding the use of ETFs in 2011/12. Satisfaction levels remain high (equity ETF satisfaction rates have been consistently in the region of 90%), and there has been an increase in the use of ETFs for corporate bonds, infrastructure and real estate.

• Demand for innovation is high in different asset categories, with 49% of respondents seeking development of emerging market equity ETFs, and there is also demand for new forms of indices, such as ‘smart beta’ ETFs, which seek to generate superior risk-adjusted returns compared to standard market-capitalisation-based equity indices.

• The great majority of European investors think that ETFs should remain as beta-producing products (81% of respondents). However, 17% of respondents were of the opinion that ETFs should become actively managed, which is an increase from just 11% in 2011.

• In July 2012, ESMA tackled the issue of investor protection from a number of different standpoints, including guidelines stipulating increased disclosure for index-tracking UCITS, increased clarity with regard to use of ETF identifiers, increased disclosure for actively-managed UCITS ETFs, management of collateral for OTC derivative transactions and guidelines for indices tracked by ETFs. These recommendations have been warmly welcomed by investors, with 77% agreeing that the guidelines have achieved their stated aim of improving investor protection.

• On the subject of revenues from securities lending, support for the ESMA recommendations is even stronger. Investors are overwhelmingly in favour of the requirement to return securities lending revenue net of costs to the ETF investor, with 84% of respondents in agreement.

• The ESMA guidelines have been informative and are setting standards in the right direction for investors in insisting on the transparency of indices globally. This overall issue of index transparency has been very positively viewed by investors.

Commenting on the results of the survey, Valérie Baudson, Managing Director, Amundi ETF, said, “Despite the growing maturity of the ETF market, this year’s survey has shown again that the level of satisfaction towards ETFs remains extremely high and that the vast majority of investors plan to increase their usage. The positive changes in investor perception regarding risks and transparency are significant developments for the industry.”

Professor Noël Amenc, Director of EDHEC-Risk Institute, added, “There is no doubt that the ETF market has evolved considerably in the past year, with a particular focus on the developing regulatory framework. Investors have sent an important message on the need for transparency to both regulators and product providers.”

A copy of the EDHEC-Risk Institute survey can be found here: EDHEC-Risk European ETF Survey 2012

See Also

- 08-09-2017
Ranked 4th in France, EDHEC reinforces its position in the world’s Top 20 (16th place) in the 2017 Financial Times Master in Management Ranking, among prestigious international institutions...
- 30-08-2017
EDHEC welcomes students and participants who are back to school in the upcoming weeks. A positive and international atmosphere (more than 100 nationalities expected) shines through our...
Innovation with limited resources (Video)
- 18-08-2017
The article "Innovation with Limited Resources: Management Lessons from the German...
Station F successfully inaugurated in the presence of Emmanuel Macron and EDHEC
- 29-06-2017
EDHEC announced this May that it had joined Station F, the world’s biggest start-up...