Comparing First, Second and Third Generation Commodity Indices

Joëlle Miffre: The rising interest of institutional investors for commodities since the early 2000s prompted remarkable financial engineering in the commodity index space which is now in its third generation.

Author(s):

Joelle Miffre

Professor of Finance, EDHEC Business School

The purpose of this article is to review this evolution and to give an assessment of index performance. Long-only second generation indices, which attempt to minimize the harmful impact of contango on performance and use active long-only signals based on momentum or roll-yields, are found to outperform their first generation counterparts. Third generation indices fare even better as they accurately buy backwardated assets and short contangoed ones, thereby reducing overall volatility. We see these indices as serious contenders to commodity trading advisors who merely replicate strategies based on momentum or term structure.

Type: Working paper
Date: le 23/11/2012
Research Cluster : Finance

See Also

Innovative research: EDHEC strengthens its leadership in infrastructure at Paris Infraweek
News
- 08-10-2019
EDHECinfra, the EDHEC research centre dedicated to infrastructure, will take part in "...
HOW NEW ACADEMIC PROGRAMMES ARE BORN
News
- 02-10-2019
HOW DID THE PROGRAMME COME INTO BEING? It all started in 2016. At that time, EDHEC did...
Predictive justice: failsafe or false promise?
Publication
- 02-10-2019
Justice in trial The determination (or perception, depending on the case) of justice in...
EDHEC teams up with Coursera to launch MOOCs in machine learning techniques for financial-sector professionals
- 01-10-2019
EDHEC-Risk Institute, EDHEC Business School’s financial research hub, has teamed up...