From Deterministic to Stochastic Life-Cycle Investing: Implications for the Design of Improved Forms of Target Date Funds

In an attempt to address the concern over financially illiterate individuals being increasingly responsible for investment decisions related to retirement risk, the financial industry has started to design dedicated mutual fund products known as target date funds.

Author(s):

Lionel Martellini

Professor of Finance at EDHEC Business School and Scientific Director of EDHEC-Risk Institute.

Vincent Milhau

Senior Research Engineer at EDHEC-Risk Institute

These funds, whose aim is to provide investors with one-stop solutions to their life-cycle investment needs, typically propose a deterministic decrease of equity allocation until a date called the target date of the fund. This approach, however, has been found inconsistent with the prescriptions of standard life-cycle investment models (Viceira and Field 2007). In this paper, we characterise in closed-form the optimal time- and state-dependent allocation strategy for a long-term investor preparing for retirement in the presence of interest-rate and inflation risks and a mean-reverting equity risk premium. We confirm that existing target date fund products are the wrong answer to the right question, and the opportunity cost involved in purely deterministic life-cycle strategies is found to be substantial for reasonable parameter values. Surprisingly, perhaps we also find that even reasonably fine partitions of the set of investors and market conditions, only marginally more complex than current partitions based solely on time horizon, allow substantial welfare gains compared to existing target date funds. Our results have important practical implications since they suggest that a parsimonious set of life-cycle investment benchmarks can be designed, which could serve as relatively accurate proxies for a whole range of retail investors' optimal long-term investment strategies.

Type: EDHEC Publication
Date: le 30/09/2010
Research Cluster : Finance

See Also

A career shift thanks to EDHEC
News
- 15-07-2019
Xiangming Bei, from China, joined EDHEC after a 4-year Bachelor’s degree in management...
PUBLICATIONS
News
- 12-07-2019
The paper titled “Emerging market equity benchmarks for Japanese investors: countries,...
Finance: New certificates available in September 2019
News
- 12-07-2019
Want to add a new competency to your financial skillset? Premier academic centre for...
Endurance sport: leaving yourself behind
News
- 09-07-2019
Lionel Martellini has been leading the EDHEC-Risk Institute since 2015. A world-...