How Costly Is Regulatory Short-Termism for Defined-Benefit Pension Funds?

The recent pension crisis has triggered a fierce debate in most developed countries between advocates of tighter regulation designed to provide explicit incentives for pension funds to increase their focus on risk management and those arguing that imposing short-term funding constraints and solvency requirements on such long-term investors would only increase the cost of pension financing.


Lionel Martellini

Professor of Finance and Scientific Director of the EDHEC Risk and Asset Management Research Centre.

Vincent Milhau

Research Engineer, EDHEC Risk and Asset Management Research Centre

We analyse this question in the context of a formal continuous-time dynamic asset allocation model for an investor facing liability commitments subject to inflation and interest rate risks. In an empirical exercise, we find that the presence of short-term funding ratio constraints indeed involves a positive welfare cost, but that cost is not found to be prohibitive for reasonable parameter values. Recognizing that the presence of minimum funding ratio constraints, whether desirable or not, should affect the optimal allocation policy, we then provide the formal solution to the asset allocation problem in the presence of such constraints. We compare these risk-controlled strategies to unconstrained allocation strategies coupled with additional contributions, and find that the latter involve severe welfare costs in the presence of irreversible contributions and regulatory shorttermism, especially when marginal utility decreases sharply beyond a given threshold. In essence, we show that risk-management strategies can turn irreversible contributions and short-term constraints into reversible contributions and long-term constraints. Overall, our results suggest that it is not so much the presence of short-term funding ratio constraints that is costly for pension funds as their reluctance to implement risk-management strategies that are optimal given such regulatory constraints.

Type: Position paper
Date: le 06/10/2008
Research Cluster : Finance

See Also

- 21-10-2021
Agora students held another 'Rencontre de l'Agora' event on Wednesday 19 October, this...
Eiffel Excellence Scholarship: the most prestigious French scholarship you can get
- 21-10-2021
Mikhail Miroshnichenko joined EDHEC MiM Finance after his Bachelor’s degree in...
EDHEC-Auchan Learning Partnership: Retail industry transformations at the heart of EDHEC International BBA learning
- 20-10-2021
Auchan is joining forces with EDHEC to share its retail industry expertise with EDHEC...
The FIR-PRI Awards “Finance & Sustainability” prize for “best pedagogical innovation”: preparing future generations to fight climate change.
- 18-10-2021
At EDHEC, we want to take part in the fight against climate change. Through our...