Alternative Measurement Bases in Pension Accounting: A Simulation Analysis

This paper explores the financial statement implications of alternative measurement bases underlying defined benefit pension accounting rules via a simulation analysis.

Author(s):

Paul Klumpes

Professor of Financial Accounting, EDHEC Business School

Simulation analysis can be used to examine the effect of alternative discount rate assumptions on the strength of associations between an economic or generational accounting basis, an actuarial funding basis of measurement and two alternative accounting measurement bases of pension assets and liabilities; value-in-use and value-in-exchange. Accounting measures are found to be more highly correlated with economic unfunded pension liabilities when they are discounted using market instead of value in use rates. The value at use rates are also more highly sensitive to differences in funding method, real versus nominal interest rates and plan initiation dates. The findings suggest that the use of alternative measurement bases for pension reporting and funding involves a trade-off between the relevance and reliability of the resulting pension disclosures. The transparency of reported corporate pension exposure would be improved through enhancing the logical consistency between combining key discount assumptions and various measurement bases. We also develop policy implications concerning the appropriateness of alternative measurement bases in reporting by various types of reporting entity, and propose the re-classification of various liability and equity-related components of pension contracts.

Type: Working paper
Date: le 21/10/2010
Research Cluster : Finance

See Also

PUBLICATION
News
- 21-05-2019
The article titled “KIDZ Beating The Market? A Case For Children-Focused Thematic Index...
EDHEC organises the first business school hackathon at  VivaTech, and focuses it on career orientation for youngsters
News
- 21-05-2019
  EDHEC & Vivatech: a long-lasting partnership   In partnership with VivaTech since...
The EDHEC case study “Maison Maille” won the 2018 Emerald Best Case Award
News
- 17-05-2019
We are very proud to announce that “Maison Maille: making mustard aspirational to...
EDHEC Tomorrow - Horizon 2030
News
- 16-05-2019
As part of the preparation of the 2020-2025 strategic plan, we wish to open the debate...